My Cart

Close

Forgot How Much Fun It Is To Have Rising Fish To Cast At.

Posted on July 19 2025

Just so you know, I read and learn from the comments. I have heard of numerous encounters with stripers this year following the two months of high water. Butch's post about someone catching 5 is still unsettling. Hopefully anyone catching one above Callicoon makes sure that it has eaten it's last trout. Congrats to Ed S. who caught two nice fish on sulfurs after taking a bath in sub 50 degree water. My hands would have been shaking so hard I couldn't have tied on a fly.  Max, was encouraged by your report and enjoyed a nice night because of it. If you are still in Sylvan Beach in mid August, drive up to McConnelsville and check out the Ephron hatch. The West Branch of Fish Creek was one of my old haunts and the hatch is incredible. From McConnelsville to Blossvale is quite remote and has some big fish. (Now everyone knows why I can't comment on comments and congratulate successful anglers.)

Decided to take in the sulfur hatch on the UEB, left at 1:30, drove up route 30 looking for, but not expecting to see, sulfurs and risers, and didn't until I was above Corbett. Hit the trifecta at the Abutment Pool, sulfurs, rising fish, and a fisherman. Waved and took option #2, a long walk through a knee high hay field that was freshly mowed the last time I was there. Did so without knowing if the path through the cane to the river was still open. It was, sorta, made my way through stomping down cane stalks as I went ***, got to the river and fished down a couple hundred yards without seeing a rise. Finally where the run dumps into the pool were a few fish rising, but not eating the sulfurs. Like the WB there were also some tiny olives on the water, I tied one on, and in a very enjoyable half hour, hooked four fish. One came at me a good six inches to eat the fly on what was a short cast. The fly pulled out of his mouth. The other three all were landed, the fourth was an 18 incher that ate three flies, each one closer to me. Made my cast and it drifted six feet past where he last rose before he opened his mouth and inhaled the fly. Walked back to the car not minding one bit that I was stepping on freshly spread manure.  

Drove back to the Lordville Estate, arriving at 4:30, rested up and was in the car at 6:00 ready to again try to find an evening hatch of sulfurs on the WB. Selected a pool above Hale Eddy, sure I was two hours too early, walked in and had rising fish from then 'til dark. 

How'd I do?  All the long suffering WB anglers, take heart, got my ass kicked, hard and often. There was a perfect sulfur hatch, (enough to get fish up, but not so many that they wouldn't see your fly. Got refused over a dozen times by fish sipping duns. The two anglers fishing above me walked by on the way home saying that they were really fussy today, the boat that sat in the honey hole for the last hour rowed by saying that they had had an epic battle with a big fish,(I didn't ask the outcome). It was more than an hour before a fish took mercy on me, ate the sulfur, raced across and up stream, catching the leader under a rock and is now wearing an A119 sulfur with three feet of 6x. Thereafter things got a little easier, hooked and landed three fish before it went quiet while there was still light in the western sky.

Yesterday I said don't come if you have to drive home in the dark. If you would have promised me the action I had today, I would have come, stopped at Wendy's, bought the magnum coffee and driven home in the dark with a big smile on my face.

*** Trails - Last I checked the government doesn't clear trails for fishermen. We have to do it ourselves. If you are from out of town, break off the cane, pick up sticks and small limbs that have fallen on the trail as you walk to and from your car. If you're a resident, bring your pruning shears if you know there is an obstruction in the path you are going to use. The cane can close off access to a pool in less than a week, we need everyone's help to keep trails open. 

8 comments

  • Anonymous : July 20, 2025

    The stripers are native to the river and the brown and rainbow trout are not. It’s illegal to kill a striper below 28 inches or above 35 inches in the main stem.

  • Jim Dygert: July 20, 2025

    This report brings back memories of Fish Creek near McConnellsville..Bud Radigan turned me on to this stream in the 70’s for the incredible Hendrickson hatch..parked at the bend pool and worked upstream to and past the trestle..you could at times run into a nasty batch of lampreys but the fishing was always good..haven’t been back in years and I’m pretty sure it is well posted…stay safe!

  • Jim N: July 20, 2025

    A119,
    Great report. It’s nice to see the fishing window opening up beyond 1-2 hours.

  • Anonymous : July 19, 2025

    Still stripers up as far as Corbett, with a significant amount at any large pool moving down river.

  • Ed Smith: July 19, 2025

    Angler119’-Thanks for the congrats. I appreciate it. Fortunately it was90 degrees out that day , so I warmed up quickly ( or I’m not smart enough to quit)Kudos for finding rising fish and landing an 18” er on the UEB. Very cool. I not familiar with the Abutment Pool. Do you park at Corbett and walk up river? Good luck to all this weekend. Ed

  • Dennis: July 19, 2025

    Fished the upper west yesterday afternoon and did ok. I landed 2fish 12in. And had numerous refusals!! I had a good one break me off. I stayed till 5:30 and it went dead. I
    I am heading out this afternoon and will report.
    A119 great day!! Congrats

  • Keith: July 19, 2025

    A lovely report and a joy to read. Thank you!

  • Max: July 19, 2025

    A119,

    Glad to hear you had a good day. I fish with my father-in-law who is very familiar with the Ephron hatch and you have him all riled up now this morning! I haven’t fished fish creek yet this year but my friend and I have been to the Mohawk and pulled some beautiful fish out of there this year. We will definitely try out the Ephrons this time around.

    We had a good day on the river here yesterday, leaving the cabin to head upstream around 12:30. We landed at the new parking spot in deposit (which is a great new addition and nice place for my father-in-law) to access the flat below the bridge and rifle under the train tracks. Within 15min we had active participants feeding on emerging sulfers and duns here and there. I got a hot 17” rainbow on an iso while I searched around for my spot, coming out of the water 3 times before I got him to the net. Then, I found the fish I was looking for. A slow dun sipping brown that was sure to be the fish of the weekend for me. I worked him for a while, rested him avidly while I shot at different targets and changed flys. I found the dun he was looking for, got a take, set the hook and he was there for a split second and then gone. Heartbreaking.

    The evening fishing was tough as others would say but the amount of targets and perfect mix of spinners and sulfer duns made it a great evening to be on the water.

Leave a comment

Join our Mailing List

Sign up to receive our Newsletter!

My Cart

Subtotal: $ 0.00

Your cart is currently empty.